Saturday, July 24, 2010

On Women

Women's Studies is an emerging area in humanities and social sciences. It is an interdisciplinary course that focuses on the roles, experiences, and achievements of women in society.

However, it is premised on the notion of gender asymmetry. When enlarged upon it simply means that women are always at the periphery, suffer from inequalities and occupied a subservient position in relation to man.

There is no argument in that notion as it is amply borne out by newspaper and television reportings of,particularly in India, dowry deaths, honour killings,amniocentesis , rape and so on.

But we must not lose sight of the fact that women are life-givers.Women not only give birth;but also provide nourishment to the newborns. And about India whatever you rightly say , the opposite is also true.

Today I want to paint a different picture of women's status in ancient India. And it is bound to 'shake us aware like a blow on the skull'.

Here is Gargi- a woman scholar of vedic India.She is in 'arguing combat' with formidable Yajnavalkya.She challenges Yajnavalkya in front of the learned Brahmins to answer her questions. She says:'If he (Yajnavalkya) is able to answer those questions of mine,then none of you can ever defeat him in expounding the nature of God'. How bold she is! And her intellectual prowess! She is convinced her questions are the most insightful. And mind the rhetoric in which her questions are couched:' Yajanvalkya, I have two questions for you.Like the ruler of Videha or kashi , coming from a heroic line, who strings his unstrung bow, takes in hand two penetrating arrows and approaches the enemy, so do I approach you with two questions , which you must answer.'

Maitreyi,Yajnavalkya's wife raised profoundly philosophical question:' shall I achieve immortality if the whole earth, full of wealth were to belong to me'?When Yajnavalkya answered in the negative, she remarked:'What shall I do with that by which I do not become immortal'?

Women depicted in epics,classical tales and in recorded history, do not always conform to the tender and peace-loving imagae that is often assigend to women.

Draupadi speaks to a reluctant Yudhistra with an exhortation to fight:'For a woman to advise a man like you/is almost an insult. Yet my deep troubles compel me to overstep the limit of womanly conduct/make me speak up'.

To be continued...

Tuesday, June 29, 2010

A Tribute to Jose Saramago

Jose Saramago is dead. Dead with him is an era.

His narrative, very often, was an exploration of the possibility of fiction. If there was a global novelist, it was surely Saramogo. He wrote in Portuguese;but his works are being translated into several languages.

Saramago's 'The Gospel according to Jesus Christ' raised many a hackles for its bold treatment of Christ and Christianity. He posits Christ along the fault line between devil and God. His Christ is a man of flesh and blood just like you and me. Thus he challenged hagiographic biography and attempts to instill heterodoxy into the framework of organized Christianity.And raises questions about orality and texuality. His treatment of the relation between Jesus and Mary Magdalene is human and morally outrageous. I have liked this book more than Kazhanjaki's 'The last temptation'.

'The Double' is branded as an existential novel in which the protagonist meets his own lookalike. They are so alike that their voices too are same. The story unfolds with many twists and turns and opens before us a surreal world.

'The History of the siege of Lisbon' will surely interests those who are passionate about alternative history. The story involves about a proofreader's mistake , his effort to rewrite the siege of Lisbon and in the process he writes his own love story.

Most profound is his 'Death in intervals'. A novel suffused with magic realism. On the first day of the year in an unnamed country no body dies. It is a bizarre situation. If there is no death, there is no resurrection, if there is no resurrection, there is no Christianity...no one buys insurance,hospitals are full...people are in 'suspended life' or in 'arrested death'.The novel shows how important the death is for us. Also raises question:Is temporality a necessary condition for existence? He equates death with God...like God death is omnipresent(I may die now while writing this). Most interestingly he personifies death as a mysteriously clad woman.
I will not go any further lest your curiosity cools. Just read it.

In the hurly-burly of our collective lives, his death went unnoticed. No Assamese paper mentioned( I will be happy if I am proved wrong) his death even in the last page.(And also no Assamese news channesl who extol one special Assamese as 'thinker' (Chintabid) who was caught red handed while stealing materials for a school level textbook on environmental sciences).

I feel all genuine literature should aspire to the condition of the narrative that Saramago ushered in.

I think I can not expect a second Saramago in this life.

Sunday, May 16, 2010

The File On MB

An unknown teacher of English from a provincial town in Assam has been shot into 'eminence' for all the wrong reasons.

Marshaling all the hate-words under his command , he has constructed a vituperative edifice of his observations on the Assamese community. Prima facie it reads like a 'drain inspector's report'.

Maybe he is under the delusion that falsehood mongering is edifying.

Now the big question:howshall we react?Shall we burn him at the stake?

The answer is simple: No/Never.

Conceding the' epistemological fragility' of knowledge, we feel that knowledge largely comes through a dialectical process. Instead of 'blowing hot and cold',we must erect our counter arguments and thereby hammer home the fact that we are not as black as we are painted.

And for that, our architects and the skilled workers will be his fraternity-the teachers.
Russell in his essay 'The Functions of a teacher'rightly points out:' The defense of the state in all civilized countries is quite as much in the hands of teachers as in those of the armed forces.'
We can go one step farther and add 'community' to the state.While mounting a counter attack( I am aware I am using the metaphors of war. Newspaper reporters have given the verdict that it is an attack against our community), we must keep in mind that we are a civilized community and civilization is more importantly 'a thing of the mind'.And if he opens the flood gates of vitriol again, we will request him as Mr. Gladstone(sometime British Prime Minister) requested from his political opponent :"...to extend to[us] that large measure of courtesy which, were [we] in his place and he in [our],we should most unhesitatingly extend to him".

Also we will ensure that nobody does nay harm to him because we are civilized and we endorse 'the kind of tolerance that springs from an endevour to understand those who are different from ourselves'.

Tuesday, April 27, 2010

Bihu Musings

This is my 'fortieth year to heaven'.Indeed a long enough time to do some stock-taking.During these forty years' round up of my life,three books have robustly influenced my mental world. One of them is Schumacher's 'Small is beautiful.' I draw your attention to the following lines from the book: 'The prestige carried by people in modern industrial society varies in inverse proportion to their closeness to actual productions'.

The Bihu is a festival that has evolved out of the rituals connected with 'Fertility cult'.Primarily it is a festival which is inextricably bound up with agriculture or with the people engaged in agricultural activities. In other words this festival carries within itself a world view based on an all pervading spirit in nature.
But the 'heady paroxysm of sumptuous rituals' with which the Bihu is celebrated in our city hardly contains even a trace element of that. On the contrary it is devalued, debased and highly commercialized in the hands of materialist and spiritually bankrupt(by spirituality I do not mean rituals) city dwellers.

The so called artists who blabber till the dawn breaks are miles farther from real production. The girls whose dances are sophisticatedly choreographed for public (mainly man) gaze have never seen a paddy field let alone doing chores agricultural. The farmer who toils from dawn to dusk and as a result ages prematurely, is banished from this scheme of things. And the rest snatches all the glory.

It really pains me.

Wednesday, April 7, 2010

Emtional distance and mobile phone

The advent of mobile phones signalize a remarkable change in our daily lives. A day without this small gadget is unthinkable.

Besides many other things, mobile phones have significantly narrowed the emotional distance of our hearts.

My family and I live apart in a distance of 120 Kms.The mobile phone that I use cannot reduce this physical distance. But emotionally I am always with them. In other words I carry my family and the dear and near ones(You are included) in my pocket. Of course metaphorically. Whenever I have the urge to talk(You are included again) to them, I fish out my mobile phone and my wish is instantly realized.(We are living in an age of instancy--instant coffee, instant noodles...right?) Be it on a busy street or in my small cozy room or during a comfort break in prolonged official meeting.

Now read the following poem by late Bireswar Baruah roughly translated by yours truly:

' Rays from the stars travel for many light- years to reach us.
I get your news from a different town.
The gap between what I get and what I do not,
seems to be a distance of light-years.'

Surely the poem talks about emotional distance in pre-mobile times.(Bireswar Baruah did not have a mobile when he wrote this I am sure).

A person like me who sleeps with the mobile phone is incapable of comprehending such a thought. And I am sure 'I am not the only one'.

Mobiles phones are bound to rob us of such transcendent poetry.

Wednesday, March 24, 2010

There is a grammatical convention that every verb must have a subject. Nietzsche contests this idea. He says:' a thought comes when 'it' wants to , and not when 'I want it to.'But can thought exist without a thinker?
Where does a thought originate? Obviously in my mind. But what is mind?Is it a thing? A substance?
Mind is the stuff that thoughts and dreams are made of. Mind is holistic. It does not occupy a location. Let me tell you an anecdote: A cosmonaut and a brain surgeon talk. The cosmonaut says I have traveled miles and miles in space, but I have never seen an angel or God.The brain surgeon says: I have performed hundreds of brain surgery, but I have never seen mind. So again where does mind exist?
Let me give an example: There exists a university in Guwahati and there exists a Sunday.Both are correct.But it would be meaningless to place University and Sunday alongside each other and discuss their interrelations. Again it is meaningless if I ask : What stuff is the mind made of?It is as good as asking what stuff your citizenship or Sunday are made of.
Is it a brain cell activity?( I know you are thinking now.)
To talk of mind in a place is just misconceived. It is just like light: sometimes particle(photon) and sometimes wave(Quantum).Sometimes a thought process and sometimes a neural activity.
I have a mind(or for that matter you have a mind) is a matter of faith because neither of us can see each other's.
My mind is not a chattel: it is me. It is my thoughts and experiences. So my blog is 'My mind'.

Let me conclude with the following classical statement:'...to seek self-knowledge is to embark on a journey which ...will always be incomplete.'

Sunday, December 20, 2009

I am fortunate!

'...men have little time to be boys and some never were,as is known and has been written, while others have never stopped being boys but dare not admit it'-The History of the seige of Lisbon by Jose saramago.

My pet name is Rinku. If I live long enough to be an old man; my name will continue to carry the boyish impression. Have you ever thought what your name carries when you are old?
It is my name that matters (what is there in a name...) and I dare admit it.

My passport says that I am 40 . But in my fancy I am still a 17 years boy.

...and I dare admit it.