Sunday, March 13, 2016

India- an 'imagined reality'.

Ever since the Cognitive Revolution human beings have been living in two realities. One is a concrete reality that can be grasped by our senses. For instance the reality I am presently in with my laptop and the coconut tree that stands tall beyond my window.
On the other hand there exists a powerful reality that lies beyond our immediate senses. That is ‘Imagined reality’. Imagined reality consists of legends, myths, Gods and religion-all those things that appeared for the first time with the Cognitive revolution And needless to say that this reality is more powerful than the concrete reality that we are used to. Noah Harari in his Book ‘Sapiens- A brief History Of Humankind’ and particularly in the chapter  ‘The legend of Peugeot’ has skilfully shown how an imagined reality like Peugeot- a corporate car manufacturer was created. In much the same way an ‘imagined reality’ called India has also been created with instrument such as the constitution to which we all owe allegiance.
This ‘Imagined reality’ has enabled us not merely to imagine things ,but to do so collectively. India is ,in fact , a collective ‘imagined reality’.  Harari has shown how collectively we can weave myths such as the biblical creation story.
Notwithstanding a distinct geographical boundary and a concrete map, India is an idea- a collective ‘imagined reality’ as stated earlier.  Without doubt my idea of India may not match with that of yours. Yet we weave collective myth about it and we share them.

 We must nurture this ‘imagined reality’ of our land. And must not allow anything that might distort this ‘imagined reality’. Can we ?

Monday, July 6, 2015

The Art and Craft of approaching your head of department to submit a request for a raise

In a letter to Louise Colet, Flaubert expressed his wish to write a book about nothing, a book that would be held together by the mutual tension of its component parts rather than by its correspondence to any real world.
This is what aptly describes Georges Perec’s small novel  entitled ‘The art and craft of approaching your head of department to submit a request for a raise’.
Georges Perec(1936-82) is a writer of acrostics,anagrams,autobiography poetry, plays and so on. He famously wrote a whole novel without using the letter ‘e’(The Void).

Along with Italo Calvino andRamaond Queneau, he belonged to a movement called ‘oulipo.’ Founded in 1960 this literary movement has a number of mathematicians too as its members that seek to create ‘new structures and patterns which may be used by writers’ in any way they like.
Perec was thrown a challenge of using a computer’s basic mode of operation as a writing device , procedure was sketched out that an employee would need to follow to obtain an increase in pay in some large organization. Then it was broken down into individual steps and laid the procedure out as algorithm , or flow chart. Perec accepted the challenge wrote the book ’The art and craft of approaching your head of department to submit a request for a raise’.
There is no clear cut storyline  in the book as it seems a low level functionary of a large organization summons up courage to meet his head of department to request for a raise. But in the process he seems to have followed the flow chart and ultimately he never reaches his HOD.

The book is a long sentence as there is no comma or full stop. Sentences are refrains and are often convoluted as in page number 40.  I quote:’…you know that he knows that you know and he knows you know that he knew that you saw that he would know that you were about to know…’
As in the Love song of J. Alfred Prufrock the song was never sung , likewise this low level functionary of a large corporate house could never meet his HOD to submit a request for a raise. Like a bull in a press, he simply follows the flow chart and reaches nowhere.
The book is a delightful and intellectually enriching reading experience

Thursday, June 12, 2014

Wordsworth's Daffodils

I wondered lonely as a cloud
That floats on high o’er vales and hills,
When all at once I saw a crowd,
A host, of golden daffodils,


These lines from Wordsworth’s Daffodils are so deeply ingrained in us that it is very difficult to read them with detachment. The poem sums up many of the themes that are associated with Romanticism-themes such as subjectivity and imagination.
Although Wordsworth saw the Daffodils long time back , there is a sense of immediacy and involvement. It follows that along with subjectivity and imagination , it is memory that too plays a pivotal role in Romantic tradition in general and in this poem in particular.

Everybody would agree that we can never go back to our ‘good old days’ however hard we are whipped by the strongest sense of nostalgia. The concept of time machine or the theme in ‘Back to future’ are still in the realm of idea. Therefore there is no other option but to ride piggy back on memory that alone can transport us back to the past.
It is memory for which I am who I am or you are who you are. All the time throughout our lives we are engaged in creating memory right from the moment we wake up till the time we hit the bed. Memory is what creates our lives’ coherent narrative. What happens just in case there is a suppression of links in the chain of our memory? We cease to be who we are. Just imagine Wordsworth  had a highly fragmented memory? We could never have Daffodils in its present form. Wordsworth might have resorted to meaningless confabulations. It is only for his coherent memory that Wordsworth could write:

   For oft ,when on my couch I lie
   In vacant or in pensive mood,
   They flash upon that inward eye
   Which is the bliss of solitude;

 Daffodils is nothing but the celebration of human memory.


( After reading Oliver Sacks)

Wednesday, February 26, 2014

On Death and Dying



‘Life is an uncertain adventure in a diffuse landscape, whose borders are continually shifting, where all frontiers are artificial, where at any moment everything  can either end only to begin again or finish suddenly, for ever and ever ,like an unexpected blow from an axe. Where the only absolute,coherent, indisputable and definitive reality is death’. ( From The Flanders Panel by Arturo Perez Reverte)


 Temporality is the fundamental law of existence. Anything that is living today has to die a death sooner or later.  Yet we are so obsessed with the business of living that we hardly situate a thought on death in a narrative that is understood by all. This existential question is often considered as an old age luxury.  It is because of the belief that an awareness about the uncertain length of life may be a hindrance in the ascent of man whereas, on the contrary, many who sense impending death have hastened their contributions to humanity.

 Oddly enough man is the only creature who lives in the perpetual shadow of death. He is the only creature who is aware of death in the scathological sense of heaven or hell.

A quest for death merely for some metaphysical experience is rather rare although our myths are ridden with altruistic suicides. What we ‘modern’ men call euthanasia is still a hotly debated issue across the world.

On the other hand a search for the fountain of youth and immortality has always fired the imagination of everybody. Greek legend tells that Eos, the Goddess of the dawn married a mortal Tithonus. But while the Goddess remained eternally young (Even without using Pond’s Miracle),Tithonus began to age . So Eos begged Zeus to make Tithonus immortal. But Eos forgot to ask for the eternal youth that had to accompany the immortality. Zeus granted her wish. Tithonus became a shriveled cripple who incessantly babbled to himself. Gods became so disgusted with him that he was changed into a Cicada. So it follows that an immortal life without the attendant vigour and vitality is a real curse.

What happens if nobody dies? Saramago has given a very good description of such a situation in  his ‘Death at intervals’. In a nameless country all of a sudden people achieve immortality. Hospitals are full with terminally ill patients ;but they do not die. The patients and their relatives have a harrowing time. People met with terrible accidents yet never died.  Insurance business collapses and the Church became irrelevant as there was no death ; there has to be no resurrection or kingdom of God. Alongside a syndicate emerges who smuggle, against hefty amount, the terminally ill patients to the neighbouring countries so that they die a quiet and unknown death there.
However, in reality nobody can achieve such an eternal life( however useless and boring that might be). The physics of aging and dying tells us that as we age our ‘entropy’ increases in accordance with the Second law of Thermodynamics. Also we age and eventually die because of the ‘oxidative damage’ that the business of living inflicts on our body and mind. If the ‘entropy’ is decreased and the ‘oxidative damages’ can be minimised, human beings one day might not age and die. This idea  is,of course, still in a nascent stage.
A man can die in a variety of ways. Does not it remind us the fact that in a game of Cricket a Batsman can be out in a variety of ways?

Above all a man can kill himself. Sometimes the reason for killing oneself remains unclear. Every man( woman too) has a deep and dark recess of his own self to which access is not allowed. Sometimes a strange fear can be a reason for killing oneself. Jack London committed suicide by hanging himself from the ceiling because every night he dreamt that he drowned in sea and died. He did not like the idea of dying by drowning. So he killed himself in a way he liked ( I found this information in Murakami’s After the quake. So still I am unsure if it is fact or a highly fictionalised account).
Can there be a romantic idea of dying? If there were one, I am sure it is not a sudden ;but one surrounded by dear and near ones. And that too in a ripe age and after a brief illness.

Personally I have always liked Sudhir Kakar’s statement that I always tell my friends who are in medical profession:’ Medicines exists to fight disease; not death. When death comes holding hands with disease, it is the duty of the physician to prepare his patients for its arrival’.


A kind of peaceful and collaborative death.

Tuesday, January 14, 2014

On The Objectivity Of Science

A handsome man, seemingly  a man of science wearing a white coat appears on the Television screen and tells us how the health drink Horlicks has been found to be immensely beneficial in improving both the health and mind among young children. The visual, in order to back up the claim flashes young, healthy and  noisy children bustling with all the trappings of good health and mind. We the lay people lap up literally  what the handsome man in the advertisement announces because it is deeply ingrained in us that science is always non-partisan. Although it is questionable if the claim can stand to scientific test.

The commercial exploitation of science for its perceived strength of unbiased role(in knowledge production)) can be traced back to 1941 in the Chesterfield cigarette advertisement that depicted  researchers measuring nicotine  and thereby promoting the brand for its relatively low nicotine level.

Naturally questions will arise how science as an academic pursuit can be faulted on this count. It is the practitioners of science who are to be blamed. That is the crux of the matter that I wish to highlight. Those who may view science as a disembodied entity might hold a different viewpoint.

How ideology can privilege one set of scientific hypothesis over another can be found in the claims of Trofin Lysenko(1898—1976)an agronomist from former Soviet Union who argued in favour of the inheritance of acquired characteristics. In other words according to Lysenko mangoes can be grown in coconut trees. His method of mutating crops by ‘vernalization’ was tested in many countries and found to be false.
Interestingly it reminds me Bulgakov’s novel The Heart of a Dog in which a doctor implants a  human heart( other organs too including testicles) into a street dog assuming in the manner of Lysenko that the dog will exhibit behaviour that are human. Unfortunately the experiment goes awry and the dog becomes an intractable menace.  I often think that the novel is nothing but a lampooning of Lysenko’s outlandish idea.

Yet the Lysenko hypothesis found favour with the Soviet regime because it is in line with the party’s ideology. In recent times the Steady state Theory that postulates that the universe has no beginning and no ending and it just is , finds support among the Marxist disciples simply for the reason that it precludes the need for a creator. In both the case I feel the scientific claim here is ideologically deterministic.

‘Forman Thesis’ named after the American science historian argues that the content of early Quantum Mechanics was shaped by the culture in which it was produced. It was the unexpected defeat of Germany in the first world war that prompted the scientists to accept the uncertainty principle put forward by Werner Heisenberg rather than alternate interpretations of Quantum Mechanics.

The title of Bruno Latur’s book’ Laboratory Life:The Social Construction Of Scientific facts(co written with Stephan Woolgar) is a pointer to the fact that even scientific facts can also be socially constructed.
A scientist is not a disembodied entity that toils day in and day out inside a laboratory. He or She is also a human being like you and me and is influenced by what goes around him or her.
In recent times our state has witnessed a massive uprising in the form of public protest against the construction of big dams. Reams of paper have been used in writing in favour of or against the construction of big dams. The whole issue has become hazy for lay people as the discourse has failed to bring about a reconciliation of the opposites.
Expert committees have been constituted that voice both for and against the issue. It will be interesting to see how the uprising is going to influence the scientific truths involved in the issue. Or will  science really remain unbiased?




Tuesday, December 31, 2013

On the objectivity of Science

 When we talk about Science or Scientist , we often tend to overlook the fact that the word Scientist was coined by the British philosopher William Whewell in 1833. It follows that the scientific geniuses like Newton or Galileo were not known as ‘scientists’ during their lifetime. Although I am not sure by what names they were designated, we can always hazard a guess that they were perhaps called ‘natural philosopher’.
Nevertheless the scientific Revolution with all its ramifications have reconstructed our world views that largely started with the works of Copernicus( On the revolutions of the Heavenly Spheres,1543). With his heliocentric model of the solar system ,Copernicus dislodged Ptolemy’s geocentric model that dominated the science of astronomy for several centuries.
Equally important is the work of Andreas Vesalius( On the workings of the Human body,1543) that explained the human anatomy with considerable accuracy.  
A beginning was made that enabled human beings to understand his body as well as the universe and the inexorable march of science surged  ahead that received further momentum with the arrival of Galileo and Newton on the scene.New discoveries and inventions in Science began to play the most crucial role in furthering knowledge,driving economies and shaping cultures.  Bacon in his monumental work 'Novum Organum'(1620) went to the extend of branding printing,  gunpowder and compass as inventions that transformed literature, warfare and navigation.   Scientific study of every conceivable phenomena under the sky with its emphasis on instrumentalism, empiricism and above all falsifiable hypothesis came to acquire the status of an absolutely objective academic discipline. Everyone started to believe that science is objective and unlike humanities beyond personal whims and caprices.
This was the view about science for long. But is science really neutral?  Can science and scientific theory  ever be influenced by ideas of culture? Language? Or ideology?

I shall try to throw some  light on it in my next post.

Friday, November 1, 2013

The Power Of Fiction

WE all love to read fiction. And many of us have tried our hands at it. Some are phenomenally successful. Some are just hopeless storytellers .

Fiction is basically the art of telling lies. The fulcrum about which the story of a narrative  rotates does not (or hardly)exist. In fact Picasso once went to the extent of telling us that all art are false.

In his essay entitled ‘The sense of an Ending’, Frank Kermode defines fiction as ‘something we know does not exist but which help us to make sense of, and move in the world’. In other words the  fictionality of a given narrative is taken for granted and in fact many a time in our day to day discourse  we invent different fictions to help us out of problem and also to perpetuate the existence of our self-serving interests. This is also to mean that arguably we need to create  fiction for the promotion of a particular idea and also the person who remains behind that idea.
A case in point is the story of the apple involving  Sir Issac Newton. It is believed that Newton’s discovery of  gravitation was occasioned by the fall of an apple when he was sitting in a contemplative mood. But many have contested the story including the celebrated Science historian I.B.Cohen. Many argue that the story of the apple is merely an invention by historians with French writer Voltaire often cited as the chief suspect.  J.B.S. Haldane , an outstanding British Biological Scientist went to the extent of suggesting that ‘the story of the apple’ was a capitalist propaganda. Nevertheless it is a beautiful story and it has helped popularise the concept of gravitation and also  the man who is behind it. Many hold the view that such a beautiful story should not be destroyed by a ‘quest for historical accuracy’.

Even the history that we read as textbooks can border on fiction. History is basically a ‘personal construct’ as the past we ‘know’ is always contingent upon our own ‘present’.
Many doubt the existence of  medieval  Ahom general Lachit Borphukan and the narrative in which he murders his own maternal uncle for the dereliction of his duty. Often it is cited as an example of a story getting influenced by the killing of Kanch in Krishna narratives.
Nevertheless the ‘story’ has helped keep alive the Assamese nationalism –a ‘story’which is invoked in time of crisis. A ‘quest for historical accuracy’ may be ill-advised in this case.

There are many organisations in Assam whose survival litany is the story of the ‘step-motherly treatment’ meted out to the state by the centre.  But the level of corruption that the state is steeped in presently and also the astronomical grants( compare it with other states) that the centre has given to our state lead us to question this view. Besides should one go by the newspapers’ reports, one is more than consternated by the amount of money that has gone back unutilised. Nevertheless it is largely a convenient fiction that guarantees the survival of many organizations.

Leaky Gut Syndrome is not a recognised medical diagnosis. Yet lot of fictionalised accounts about the ailment are doing the rounds just for the sake of selling alternative medicine. Nevertheless this ‘fiction’ is useful and  has helped thrive a business.

Examples abound.
Fiction is a part of that power which eternally desires evil which eternally desires good.

Reference:
Hopes and Impediments by Chinua Achebe
The Universe  by J.P.Mcevoy
Re-thinking History by Keith Jenkin
The history of the siege of Lisbon by Jose Saramago 



Monday, August 5, 2013

Memory and Word

An octogenarian member of our family has been behaving in a manner that is symptomatic of  early Alzheimer disease. His anterograde  memory( he fails to create memory) seems to be failing whereas his retrograde memory( he can recall his past) is more or less intact.  His case offers a striking similarity with the protagonist of Umberto Eco’s celebrated novel ‘The mysterious Flame of Queen Loana’ in which the central character suffers a cerebral stroke that results in losing his anterograde memory. In other words  he could recall his distant past and particularly what he read as he  spent much of his time amid books by virtue of his being an antique book dealer .  He asks his wife what month it is and as his wife replies that it is April, he goes into a reverie and indulges in soliloquy:” April is the cruellest month breeding lilacs out of the dead land….’an oft-quoted line from Eliot’s The Waste Land. He recalls the lines from his past reading of the text whereas he is quite oblivious of what goes around his immediate present.

The more I get closer or more I talk to this amnesiac member of our family, the more I get a sense of immediacy and involvement. Besides I feel increasingly aware of  how memory gives us a sense of continuity. I am Nayan J.Kakoty (aka NJK)-past, present and future because I have a memory. It is my memory that helps me construct the narrative of my life. I cannot go back physically to my past as the’arrow of time’ moves only toward future. But it is  through my memory I am able to go back to my past and relive those days. Remember Wordsworth’s Daffodils: ‘I wandered lonely as a cloud  that floats on high over vales and hills/when all at once I saw a crowd/a host of golden Daffodils beside the lake…’
Wordsworth saw the Daffodils long back in past and now he is just reminiscing . In other words it is with  the help of his memory Wordsworth is getting an accesses to one of his edifying experiences that happened in his past. We all carry our past in memory as Wordsworth says again in Solitary Reaper;” the music in my heart I bore ,/long after it was heard no more’.
What Happens when there is a suppression of links in the chain of our memory? Remember what happens when the king forgets about the ring in Shakuntala? Or just mark the situation Amir Khan finds himself in Ghajni.

The octogenarian member of our family has a novel way of filling up the gaps in his highly fractured memory. He often confabulates. He often invents stories that fill up the gap when his memory goes blank. And most interesting fact  is that those inventions are from his own past experiences.
Memory! What a wonderful piece of work!
Memory is life.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Why does a word exist? Does it exist for its usages? Or it exists for its existence  in dictionary?
There are many words in our( Assamese) language that are not to be  found in any dictionary. For example in my day to day life I have often overheard people saying’ Moi khai keni or moi khai pini golu( I went after I had eaten my food). The words like keni or pini (in the context of this use) are not in any Assamese dictionary. I do not know if the words are just the babbling of a dialect of Assamese. At least in standard Assamese these words are not found. Neither can they be used in the context as above.
Recently AASU demanded a Sarbic(Comprehensive)reform of SEBA(Board Of Secondary Education). But surprisingly the word Sarbic was not in ChandraKanta abhidhan. Not in Saraighat Abhidhaan either. A friend of mine told me that the word could be a derivative of Sarba(entire). I looked up and  even there too the word could not be found.
In that case it is worth-examining how the word has forged a path into AASU’s rhetoric.
These words pose the conundrum as mentioned above. Besides it also underpins the debate if  a dictionary should be prescriptive. Or whether a dictionary should be  left alone to describe the language as it is.
( After reading Lynda Mugglestone’s ‘Dictionaries: A very short introduction published by Oxford University Press)




Wednesday, July 3, 2013

Ill-starred event

This blog post might give the impression of a déjà vu as I wrote on the subject before also.

Never did I realise that a lecture on Disaster Management can be so interesting and rewarding. When a friend of mine asked me to join him in the lecture at Academic Staff College, Gauhati University, which was to be delivered by an Assam Civil Service officer from NDMA Mrs Nandita Hazarika, willy-nilly I agreed to come as I was expecting a slide show of facts and statistics from a somnolent civil servant. But to my utter surprise , it turned out to be a lecture that enriched my perception
manifold about the subject. Besides the lecture was organised at the most opportune time as India’s biggest natural disaster has badly mangled our collective unconscious. The lecture was basically about how we can mitigate the impact of a disaster (both natural and man-made)with preparedness and planning . Here was an officer with considerable oomph and zeal who knows what job is cut out for her.

The lecture set my mind in motion as nature and environment are two important issues that occupy a sizable portion of my mindscape. I searched for the etymological root of the word ‘disaster’ and found that it is a word of Italian origin of 16th century. From Italian ‘disastro’-ill-starred event,from’dis’(expressing negation)+’astro’ meaning ‘star’(From Latin ‘astrum’.) ( Oxford Dictioary of English,Second Edition,Revised)

Being an ill-starred event, no nation can avoid natural disaster. But is there no element of human intervention in natural disaster?

To my mind all the natural disasters are nothing but an extension of age-old man versus nature conflict. Western literary productions have constructed a concept of nature which was subsequently put into practice in material culture. For instance the ideas of Thomas Hobbes and John Locke suggest that nature was valueless and should be treated as man’s private property. For them the ‘state of nature’ was a primitive one. Rousseau was an exception who believed that nature was ‘purest’.
During Industrial Revolution which was considered to be the beginning of ‘modernism’, Man’s relation with nature became more exploitative as progress and development came to be regarded as man’s control over nature and environment. With that man’s attempt to subjugate nature received momentum. It may be recalled that Francis Bacon who presided over the trials of witches used the same language( that he used in the trials) when it came to subjugating nature. ‘Hound her’, ‘bind her’…these were the exact words that he used with regard to nature. Since then man’s attempt to dominate nature with complete conquest has been continuing unabated.

But this is a litany as even school children are also being told that we are living in a world that is being lost to pollution, environmental degradation and so on and therefore Time magazine can start off an article stating ‘how everyone knows the planet is in bad shape’.( The Skeptical Environmentalist by Bjorn Lomborg).
There has hardly been any attempt –which is life-affirming-to effect a reconciliation between the human and non-human world. The relation has always been exploitative. As a result nature, at times ,hits back at us with all the fury .

All told, my first statement has to be qualified as Bhupen Hazarika long back showed us in his song as to what constitutes an ideal relation between man and nature or for that matter between human and non-human world in his song(which is purported to be sung by a farmer): O mur dhoritri aai /soronote diba thai(my translation)…( O’my mother earth I prostrate myself in thine feet….I am orphan…I plead, be my mother). All other nature songs (in Assamese) are nothing but a description of beautiful nature as the subject is enthralled and spell bound. Mark the lyrics of Bishnu Rabha’s( translations are mine) :’ bilote halise dhunia podume’ (lithe lotus move and bend gracefully in water)or Jyoti Prasad’s ‘Gose gose pati dile phulore xorai(all trees are in bloom) or Nirmolprabha Bordoloi’s:’phulore mela te pokhi e geet gai…( Birds sing in this flower fair). All these songs describe nature and says nothing about our relationship with her. Bhupen Hazarika’s aforementioned song has blazed the trail.

Let our relationship with nature be like what Bhupen Hazarika’s song outlines. This relationship is life-affirming and not exploitative.
Once we cultivate this relationship I am sure there will be no man-made disaster to deal with.

Friday, May 10, 2013

TWO CULTURES

Let me begin with a quote from C.P.Snows’ 1959 Rede Lectures: “I believe the intellectual life of the whole of western society is increasingly being split into two polar groups.”  The split envisaged here by Snow between Art (by Art I include Humanities and Literature and social sciences) and pure Science is still widening and this is primarily due to the elitist attitude being harboured by  both the groups that  help perpetuate the split. Snow recounts his personal experience when he says that in  many a learned gatherings of persons belonging to the discipline of  Art he poses the question as to how many of them can really explain the second law of thermodynamics. And all  of them remain invariably silent.  Snow , however,maintains that it is as good as asking an Art student about Shakespeare.

Many men of Science believe that Art is a luxury and hardly contributes to human progress and development. 'Was this the face that launched a thousand ships....' is an articulation of aesthetic experience for the poet whereas for a man of science the 'truth' in fact is in the act of seeing. In other words the image getting captured and journeying through  Retina and finally the intrusion of brain and so on. 

But are Art and science  such watertight compartments?

I do not think so. And I am sure many of you will agree to my view.

There are many aspects of Art and Science that are shared and together further knowledge-both self-knowledge and public knowledge. Scientist writers like Fritjof Kapra, Paul Davis , Michio Kaku to name a few, have helped me straddle both the worlds. Kapra has shown us in his 'Tao of Physics' and for that matter Paul Davis in his 'God and the new physics' have clearly demonstrated how at one level particle physics and (Primarily eastern)mystical thoughts converge. In some ways Art and Science can be the two sides of the same coin. One illuminating self-knowledge and the other public knowledge. Both are inquiry into nature , the ways are different though. Art is also a discovery. An artist uses his own medium in his effort of discovery and is not aware beforehand about the nature of his discovery until the work is done. In that sense, it may be mentioned, Art is different from craft for craft knows the final shape beforehand. The medium of Science are more abstract-experiment and Mathematics. But the aim is to discover. Yet Science never knows where it is  heading for( On Science by B.K.Ridley). Both Science and Art are built on firm foundations. What was considered beautiful in past is still regarded so and inform creativity.

The  history of Art and Science are both fascinating. The growth and power of Science forced Art to focus more on subjective elements. However, both permeate each other in their growth and develpment. Hermatism of ancient Egypt helped Copernicus to conceive the idea of a helio-centric model of our solar system. We are aware how the hypothesis of hyperspace influenced Dali and Piccaso in their artistic creations (Hyperspace by Michio Kaku).

One fundamental difference between Art( Let me repeat by Art I mean Humanities and literature and Social Sciences also) and Science is that the problems in Science always converge whereas the problems in Art always diverge. All super specialists  will agree that Losartan Potassium is the most suitable drug for treating Diabetic Hypertension. On the other hand Social Scientists will debate how Diabetic Hypertension will impact social gerontology.

One thing is certain. It is foolish to view the world with the narrow view of Science. All great scientists in the world came out of the confines of their laboratories and let their world view permeate with humanistic philosophy. Einstein is  a case in point. His oft-quoted line 'Science without religion is lame,religion without Science is blind' is profoundly thought-provoking. 

So the elitist attitude harboured  by both the groups will be an impediment in the way of human progress. The need of the hour is to listen to and understand each other. That is ,I am sure going to bridge the gap between the 'Two Cultures'.




Monday, December 24, 2012

Christmas Musings

Today is 12th December, at 12 pm,12th minute and 12 seconds, the date and time will be 12//12/12/12/12/12
Maa Kasam! Sardaron ko kaun sambhalega...??

This is the message that I received on my mobile on 12th December from a fast friend of mine. And I am sure you too had received such text messages on the day.
The brouhaha surrounding the date and time as mentioned ranged across the world from Fiji to Hawaii. In Guwahati also people organised special feast to celebrate the date and time. Besides, many insisted their obstetric surgeons to perform Cesarean section in such a way that the baby is made to be born coinciding the momentous moments.

But a little reflection on the date stirs up our thoughts as to what significance the date(and time)encapsulates and also to the extent  of  casting serious doubt if at all the date has really taken place.

The celebration of this date and time means the triumph of a model which is Christian and European. The calculation of ab anno Domini is essentially christian. In early Middle Ages years were counted not from the birth of Christ ;but from the presumed creation of the world. In the seventeenth century  the protestant Issac de la Peyriere observed that the original sin involved only the descendants of Adam,not other races ,born far earlier. He was declared a heretic. China and India had flourishing civilization before the year 0. Thankfully Plato and Aristotle's births are recorded as 'before Christ'.

After the independence , the government of India constituted a commission under the scientist Meghnad Saha to examine various calendars that were in use among different communities ( Even today the Assamese have a different calendar) and the commission was dumbfounded by the bewildering number calendars that various communities in India were using(and perhaps are using at the moment). A friend from Manipur once told me that there the child's birthday is recorded from day of his or her rice ceremony. A different calendar again!

Now the most pertinent question. Was the day really 12th December?

As we know that 23rd April in 1564 is not the same as 23rd April 2012. By the mid sixteenth century, the Julian calendar had fallen ten days behind the solar year and so in 1582 Pope Gregory xiii introduced the Gregorian calendar that we follow today. Many European countries immediately made the changes. Accordingly Thursday 4 October 1582 was followed by Friday 15th October.The anti-papal England rejected the idea and did not catch up till 1752,when 2 September was immediately followed by 14 September. In other words in 1564 in England, the date referred to then as 23 April corresponds to what we would today call 3 May.
This observation ,without doubt. complicates the whole issue of 12/12/12/12/12/12.

Nevertheless a very happy Christmas to you all!


Reference:

On Anniversary by David Crystal( A lecture delivered on the occasion of 425th Anniversary of Cambridge University Press in 2009)
Five Moral Pieces by Umberto Eco(Vintage,2002)
Argumentative Indians by Amartya Sen( Penguin Books)


Saturday, November 17, 2012

Conversation with Umberto Eco



Umberto Eco appeared before me like a vision of God. Lately he has cottoned on to the fact that our state has developed a lot in the health sector and therefore he flew from Bologna to Guwahati for a consultation with a doctor from Gauhati Medical College. But as the luck would have it , there broke out a clash between the medical representatives and the doctors and as a result the OPD  was cancelled. He had nowhere to go so he came to my apartment. He was in a flowery shirt that went well with his personality and the brown corduroy that hides his well-formed legs lent  an extra dimension to his sartorial casualness. He was wearing a pair of  sports shoes.

He seated himself in the computer chair  in my small and cozy bed room that I sometimes use for reading my my electricity and medical bills.
In no time we launched ourselves into a desultory and freewheeling conversation. I hope it is conversation and not merely interrogation.  Following is an excerpt:

NJK: Ever since I read your 'The Mysterious Flame of Queen Loana' , I have become enamored of you and should you  had been a girl or a lady-as you know I have special fascination for elegant elderly lady- I would have told 'I love you' and would have sung' drink to me only with thine eyes and I shall....

UC:  Ha ha....(he laughed loudly and his chubby cheeks were sunk into tiny hollows).It is indeed a pleasure to have  a fan like you who is  half-sane and half-insane...

NJK: Can there be an absolutely sane person or mind?

UC: You are right. There can be no absolutely normal mind. The dividing line between normal and abnormal mind is very thin.

NJK: ...but where is mind?

UC: My mind is elsewhere.

NJK: Where?

UC: In the play I enjoyed last night. Bhul Nubujiba Bhupenda(Do not misunderstand Bhupenda). Oh! Just mind-blowing! The auditorium, you call it pandal right?, was crammed with spectators. Electrifying! I have come to know that the playwright has written more than thirty plays in a single year which is a remarkable feat and a record of a sort. Even Shakespeare could not write as many plays during his life time. How many did he(Shakespeare) write?

NJK: I do not know.

UC: But you told you studied literature in the university?

NJK: Yes. But that was the question which was never asked in my exams.

UC: OK. I see...

NJK:  That is a good lead-in...

UC: Which one?

NJK: Bhul Nubujiba Bhupenda...

UC:  Which way?

NJK: Bhupen Hazarika , of course...

UC: He is a great singer and composer. Bhupen Hazarika dead is more powerful than Bhupen Hazarika alive.

NJK: Very well said. Explain please...

UC: See the amount of soundbites and the reams of  paper that have been wasted on controversies surrounding him.

NJK: And the latest one...

UC:  Well Nayan, I must tell you that culture is a filtering process. What is relevant to our culture remains and irrelevants just sink into oblivion. Just see, Calpurnia was relevant as long as Ceaser was alive. After his death she became culturally(or historically) irrelevant. Have you ever inquired about Shakespeare's sons? Or about the family of Indira Gandhi's husband? They are just culturally irrelevant.  So it boils down to the fact that a singer or a writer should be judged only on the basis of his or her work.

NJK:..so it is not necessary to know how many plays Shakeapeare wrote to appreciate him?

UC: Ha...(No this time he did n't laugh loudly. He became grave instead.)

NJK: What else did you like about our city?

UC: The big garbage can without lid installed by the city's civic authority.

NJK:  A  filth phile...ha ha...

UC: No.It stirs your thought. It reminds me of your great writer Raja Rao who said that there can be no India without( I was told that there is no crow in a place called Barpeta in Assam. Is any Barpetia reading this? Can you please verify?) crow. These crows feed on those garbage. Besides this provokes us into thinking if mankind as technological beings and mankind as civilized  social beings are going hand -in -hand.

NJK: Can you crisscross the city without ever finding such a garbage can?

UC: Nayan, you have never been original. This is from Gerges Perec.

NJK: You have n't read Piere Manard?

UC: Ha ha....

NJK: no, I am serious. Can there be an Einstein  without Newton? The very concept of originality is flawed  Is Shakespeare original?

UC:    NJK ,you so-called educated people are very intelligent or rather cunning. you can rationilse . And you always rationalise to your favour.

With due apology to Umberto Eco.

For the full text of the conversation, please log onto the website: www.njkmadtalk.com

Friday, October 12, 2012

On walking and Bed


However hackneyed it might be, I must tell that walking is a good exercise. When I say walking, I mean brisk walking that works up a sweat ,helps burn extra calorie and leaves a general well-being for all of us. Health benefits that brisk walking offers to diabetics and to people with hypertension are immense. Doctors and health care professionals all across the world prescribe walking, at least for  five days in a week for all to maintain a healthy life.

On the whole walking is a part of a regimen for good health.

However, at the same time walking is a part of intellectual life also. Rousseau who wrote 'The Social Contract' also wrote ' Reveries of a solitary walker'. It follows that Rousseau conceived many of his ideas while going for a walk.So is the case with Nietzsche.Coleridge's post-dinner walk for 16 miles just to post a letter is well known. Dequincey calculated that by middle age Wordsworth walked 180,000 miles . The poet who wrote:
                              'One impulse from a vernal wood
                               may teach you more of man,
                              Of moral evil and of good,
                              Than all the sages can.'
Our existence is nothing but a succession of moments perceived through senses. I am sure Wordsworth perceived his moments through his extra-sensitive senses  while on walking tours. And subsequently he transformed them into a kind of spiritualized  emotion.

With explosion in automobile industry, peoples' mobility has largely become mechanized. However, because of the health benefits , people still walk( with a mobile in ears).

The end of walking may lead us to end of ideas also.
                                             
                                                              xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

'We spend more than a third of our lives in a bed. The bed is one of the rare places where we adopt roughly speaking a horizontal posture. The others are much more specialized : operating table,bench in a sauna,chaise-loungue,beach,psychoanalyst's couch.....' Wrote Georges Perec in Species of spaces and other pieces.
What do you keep with you when you are on bed? I keep my mobile phone. I like to sms and talk to my dear and near ones from my bed. And yes I sleep better on my own bed than some one else's. I am sure it happens with you too. Proust wrote the first sentence in his great novel'A la recherche du temps':" For a long time I went bed early'. But I cannot go to my bed early(Early to bed and early to rise makes a man healthy wealthy and wise). The temptation is always there though. And for how many people  a bed is made for? Perec writes  beautifully:' The bed is an instrument conceived for the nocturnal repose of one or two persons,but no more'. Thus he precludes a diurnal nap and a family of three or four may not like his idea. For me a bed is for one person-be it nocturnal or diurnal repose.
Bed is also a place where we dream most. Is day dreaming equally possible on bed?
 I can remember my nights of bed-wetting when I was a child and all the trouble my granny took next morning for washing the bed linens. At times I crave for a sort of oedipal nostalgia as I cannot remember when I slept with my mother last.
Like walking, I am sure, bed can also be a generator many outstanding intellectual ideas. This can be subject of good research.

What do you think...eh?

Saturday, August 18, 2012

                                            Islam and civilization

What constitutes Islam? The question assumes extraordinary significance in view of the daily news stories with war, insurgency,human misery and violence around the world with active involvement of Islamic groups or countries. It is not surprising that many of us believe that the cultures of Islamic countries are backward and Islam as  the last revealed religion in the world is conservative and often as violent and extremist.
Against this background, it has never been more timely to explore the extent to which western cultural and scientific thought is indebted to the the works of Arab and Islamic thinkers a thousand years ago.
Maybe, it is one of the drawbacks of Euro-centric education system in which the contributions of non-European and particularly Arab and Islamic world are systematically pushed to the margin or totally obliterated.

 By the way the Indian contribution to science is Zero( Pun intended).

We all are familiar with Aristotle and his contributions in various branches of human knowledge. But how many of us  know about Avicena? I am sure very few. In fact I came across this name in a historical fiction by Ken Follet(The Pillars Of The Earth). Since than I have dug as much information as possible about this polymath. Avicena was born in 980 AD and is famous as the greatest physician of the middle ages.His canon of medicine remained as standard medical text across Europe till 17th Century. But his fame does not end there. He is one of the greatest Islamic philosophers and his treaties on philosophy still stands as a pinnacle of medieval philosophy.

Another Islamic Polymath was Abu Rayhan al-Biruni. He was a philosopher,mathematician and astronomer and is considered as the father of Geology and Anthropology. Yet he is hardly known here.
The word Algebra is also Islamic in origin. However, I fail to recall the name of the mathematician and his book after which the name came into being.

We all remember Copernicus for his helio- centric model of our solar system. But it was Ibn al-Shatir( Ibn Qurra) who conceived the idea  of a helio-centric model about three centuries before Copernicus. But tragically no science textbook or book on the history of science has  ever mentioned him.

We are reliably informed that Newton is the father of Optics. But in fact Newton has always mounted the Giant who lived 700 hundred years before him. He is the Iraqi Ibn al-Haytham and is famous for his treaties on the refraction and composition of light and they are considered as seminal on the subject.

Another Iraqi Al-Jahith developed rudimentary theory of natural selection much before Darwin. That was in 9th century. His book entitled 'Book Of Animals 'speculates on how environmental factors can affect the characteristics of species forcing them for adaptation and thereby passing on those traits to future generations.

Bagdad was a seat of learning of Islamic world. It has no parallel. The city was created by the Caliph Ma'mun who was known for his unquenchable thirst for knowledge. But we can roll out the names harem-keeping Caliphs whose indulgence in carnal pleasure became synonymous with the whole Islamic culture.

Many argue that novel as a narrative form began in the Arab world. To my mind Shahrzad is the greatest story teller( Arabian Nights). Her character is shrouded with the elements of fiction though. Recently when I finished reading 'Akhenaten' by the Egyptian writer Naguib Mahfouz, I kept marveling at the art of his story telling. The novel reinforces the idea of Einstein that when there are many observers,there is bound to be many observations. Elite academics talk about Delilo's book 'The White Noise'. They will do well to read 'Akhenaten' which is much more postmodern than 'The White Noise'.

The list will go on.

When I see bearded men with piercing eyes wearing shorter-than-normal pajama and longer-than-normal kurta(never happen to be the articles of faith), happy with abandon in issuing fatwas, I pity them.

With equal passion I laugh at them who, wearing the dress in vogue,  decry Islam as the most backward of all religions.

I wish they both had revisited the glorious age of Islamic culture and civilization.

I hope my wish is being fulfilled.


Friday, July 13, 2012


Spectacle and Media saturation




There has been a growing realization within me that to be human is to live amid images where medium is the message. There has been a general proclivity for presenting everything as a spectacle.
Well! your guess is right. I am about to write about the molestation issue involving a young drunken girl -the incident that has been giving many of us a voyeuristic pleasure.

But let me address this issue of 'spectacle' on a positive note.

When the well known Italian writer Italo Calvino remarked that Galileo is the greatest writer in Italian literature, it raised many an eyebrow. It is basically because Calvino rated Galileo over Dante and we are always under the impression that Galileo was a scientist. Even Leopardi( another great Italian writer), according to Calvino owes much to Galileo. But why Galileo? According to Calvino while describing the moon Galileo did not use language as a 'neutral utensil'. He used the language 'with a continuous commitment that is expressive,imaginative,and even lyrical'. Calvino further writes:'It is first time that the moon becomes a real object for mankind'(The Literature Machine by Italo Calvino).
In other words the moon became a real spectacle for us and both weak and strong anthropic principle
played with it. 


The issue of the molestation of a young and inebriated girl now has become a real spectacle for us. For this, of course, we have no Galileo to thank. Thanks be to the our (Visual)medias for making the whole issue a real spectacle. We are arguing till the cows are coming home as to whether it was really incumbent upon the medias to dish it out for public consumption in such graphic details. whereas the real culprit is still at large( somebody has told me that he played the role of a police inspector in a TV serial).
The issue at hand , I think, cannot be looked at in an isolated manner. It is inextricably bound up with the culture of media saturation wherein a  subject( often manufactured),right from sperm donor to a raped girl,must be ever-present to quench the thirst of voyeuristic audience.


Now you must be wondering what Galileo or Calvino  does have to do with this?


 What is the relation between the monkey, who with its prehensile tail ,before thousands of years jumped from one tree to another and the Cambridge scientist Hawking who proclaims that the moment we know why we are here, we will know the mind of God.

My dear friends the relation is those 'thousand of years'.

Friday, April 27, 2012

A REAL JEWEL

There are many masters;but none is as masterly as he is! Yes, I am talking about Sachin Tendulkar. While making that statement, I am fully aware that cricket chauvinism runs across two axes, those of nation and generation(An Anthropologist among the Marxists by Ramachandra Guha).

Even his adversaries acknowledge his genius. Sometimes as openly as Shane Warne who wanted Tendulkar to sign on his T shirt.Cricket historians are unanimous that in living memory only Vivian Richards and Graeme Pollock have dominated the best bowlers in the world. Sachin Tendulkar is still doing that and he knows that if he fails, his side generally fails too. His impressive strike rate and overall mind-blowing statistics speak for themselves and it is certain that no cricketer in our life time can scale the heights that Tendulkar has perched himself on.

Aside from his cricketing genius what strikes me most about Sachin Tendulkar is his humility. It is worth our while to observe how he conducts himself off the field. He is among the few cricketers who is free from any controversy whatsoever.His stoicism and modesty are rare in an age of commodity fetishism

Man is a goal setting animal-said Chinua Achebe(Hopes and Impediments). Tendulkar has set his goal and has pursued it with dogged determination. By reasons of these two distinguishing features of his personality, I believe he can be an ideal icon, worthy of emulation and veneration for the young generations.

Many intellectuals in our state vehemently oppose the idea of conferring the highest civilian award-Bharat Ratna to Tendulkar. I have no idea who to their mind in the contemporary all pervasive  miasma of despair  can be a fit candidate for the award. Be it from the fields of politics or social work or art and literature.They seem to find themselves still under the shadow of Hazlittian statement that a chess player cannot be a great man as he leaves the world as he he found it. But Tendulkar is a real game changer.Is it not a fact that cricket is bound up with nationalism in our country? Cannot we see how the whole nation is galvanized when we are up against our next door'arch rival'? Tendulkar is a cohesive force that binds our nation together.

If my nine year old son asks me who can be his role model now: my answer without hesitation is Sachin Tendulkar.

He just deserves the award.

Sunday, March 25, 2012

Exercises In Style

POETIC



She arrives with the Sun wrapping the sky around her. White feathery clouds here and there.
I too arrive when the earth glows loudly.
Our eyes meet.
Dusts float about our gaze.


PROSAIC

She comes very early in the morning. She wears a blue Saree. It reveals as much as it hides.
I come late.
I look at her and she looks at me.
It is dusty all around.


RETROGRADE


Dusts float about our gaze as we look at each other.
I come late while she comes very early.
She wears a blue Saree. It reveals as much as it hides.

METAPHORIC


My love blows in with the light. An expansive blue encircles her. Soft milky white punctuates the blue here and there.
I glide with the Sun on my head.
Glances meet amid smoky dust.

COLOURFUL


Rosy cheeks, aglow with the Sun,comes in oceanic blue. Milky white dots the blue here and there.
The earth blazes as I come.
Blue and red pupils blend
with grey dust.


A PLAY IN ONE ACT

(ACT ONE ,SCENE ONE)

As the curtain rolls up,the white screen at the background glows with golden hue.
The girl enters the stage in a blue Saree.Lights focus on her accentuating her curves.
I enter from the other wings. The light on the screen becomes pronounced and spreads wide. All lights on.
She looks at me and I look at her. A cloud of smoke engulfs the stage.
The curtain falls.


SURPRISE

As the Sun comes up, the girls arrives. She wears a blue Saree. It hides as much as it reveals. By mid morning the boy arrives. They exchange glances. Dusts float about their gaze.
In fact the boy is me!

SCIENTIFIC


A primate(Female) appears with cosmic precision. Body colour marine with leuko(?) +++ in midriff.
I too a primate(Male. Both belong to Homo Sapiens) appear. Helios @ 90 degree.
Our vision 6/6. Collide. Suspended Particular Matter(Both positively and negatively charged). Hazy. Ocular disturbance.


Inspired by Raymond Queneau


Monday, February 27, 2012

Universal Gullibility

' So when we decide to explore human stupidity, we are some how paying tribute to this creature who is part genius,part fool' This Is Not The End Of The Book- A book of conversation between Jean-Claude Carriere and Umberto Eco curated by Jean-Philippe de Tonnac.

Umberto Eco's latest novel 'The Prague Cemetery' is a wonderfully readable narrative where history and fiction blend seamlessly leaving reader agape at the inspired twisting of fact and fiction that incapacitates him to locate where history begins and fictions ends.

It is worth our while to recall that Eco is among the few academics who is capable of coming out of the cloistered class room and strike a chord with lay readers in the role of a virtuoso storyteller. And as we know a great story teller always portrays himself in his characters, Eco claims that all the characters in ' The Prague Cemetery' are real historical figures save the narrator whose identity is shrouded with mystery-sometimes posing as a split personality contradicting himself( Do I contradict myself? yes I contradict myself because I contain multitude). We have every reason to believe that it is none other than Eco himself who is all set (re)construct seemingly non-existent conspiracy theory that dates back to the time of Barruel or maybe before.

While reading 'The Prague Cemetery', I came across the following statement made by a character that made me reflect deeply as the statement rings a bell and assumes extraordinary significance in the context of the trajectory of human evolution from Homo Riligiosus to Homo Economicus. The statement is :' Man's principal trait is readiness to believe anything.Otherwise , how could the Church have survived for almost two thousand years in the absence of universal gullibility?'

The birth of Christ as we understand by 'Immaculate Conception' is hard to believe. Any person with a scientific bent of mind fails to understand how a virgin without coming into contact with the member of an opposite sex can conceive. Yet we believed. Inquisitions happened.Crusade happened. Christianity shaped our world and civilization to a very large extent.

The Islamic sacred book The Koran is believed to have been dictated by the archangel Gabriel. Who was Gabriel? Did any body see him? But The Koran touched all aspects of human existence including matters of doctrine,social organization and legislation.

The propensity to pass myths as history is rampant in hinduism. The classic example is the Ramjanmabhoomi case that still comes back to haunt us like bubonic plague.

Astrology has survived. A planet that orbits hundreds of light years away(Light travels at a speed of 299,792 Km per second) shapes the destiny of a baby who is born out of a cesarean section in an ICU in Downtown Hospital. Can any one explain this? yet we believe.

Those who are reading newspapers these days are bound to come across how fly-by-nights NGOs and finance companies are duping common men promising double or treble the amount they put by with them. Unipay- to- you is a discourse now. Yet we believed and our money went down the drain.

The list will go on. These are nothing ;but quintessence of 'Universal Gullibility'.

Viva Gullibility.

( As I said it was the lines from Eco's 'The Prague Cemetery' that triggered my ideas. My wish is not to disrespect religion or beliefs.)

Thursday, January 5, 2012

Where The Seas Meet

Among all the songs of Bhupen Hazarika, Sagor sangam ot kotona... occupies a unique place in my mind. This song is a celebration of the indomitable spirit of life that comes alive in the dulcet voice of the late singer/composer.

The song stands out for the unique juxtaposition of physical and mental worlds and their interplay on each other. It also offers us a glimpse into the creative mind of the artist that contains multitude contradicting each other- a mind that is ill at ease as the forces inimical to culture rustle into the range of his view. As he sees them , he climbs down from the ivory tower of art and mingles himself with the real world giving vent to his apprehension and finally feels assured as the forces well- disposed toward culture are all set to take over.But he does not become complacent as he feels he has miles to go which is amply borne out by his agitating mental state.

Also is important in the song the wonderful wordplay that he indulges in-Prasanta/asanta/klanta and the paradox that seems to form the fulcrum on which the entire song clusters. The paradox of prasanta-the Pacific. The Pacific(he calls it a sea, not ocean) is supposed to be calm;but the Pacific that exists in his mind is tumultuous.

From a very early age I was drawn to this song for its rhythm and rhyming words. But over the years as I have mellowed much ,was I able to grasp its real worth. Since then a strong desire to translate this song into English nestled somewhere in my mind. As a new year begins,I feel the best way to kick start it is by translating that desire into real action.

But at the same time I am fully aware of the pitfalls that I am bound to encounter while translating this song into English. In fact a song cannot be translated as is inextricably bound up with this its tune. If only I could translate its tune too!( and capture the wordplay...) Therefore I endevour to translate the song as a poem.

Besides I a reminding myself of the essay entitled 'The Meaning Of Words' that Jawaharlal Nehru wrote(he wrote it in Hindi)as long ago as 1935 in which he remarked that language is' semi frozen thought'(Translation,text and theory edited by Rukmini Bhaya Nair). To unfreeze that thought and refreeze it into a different language is the task of a translator. And for that I am not competent enough. I have translated it the way I internalize it and not the way Bhupen Hazarika would have done it if he were to write the song in English.

Finally I believe that the reader must be treated carefully and conscientiously,but friends can be dealt with a little more cavalierly(Winter notes on Summer Impression: Fydor Dostoevsky).Needless to say my readers are my fast friends.
Well, now...

Much have I swum
where the seas meet,
Yet I am not satisfied
The waves in my mind's pacific
are still restive.

Of tidal waves there is no end
in the bosom of my mind's pacific,
endless undulations bring in
hopes in abundance.

So the waves in my mind's pacific are restive.

The peace of glorious lives along the Pacific shores
are today troubled.
With endless new formations
monsters strike relentlessly.

So the waves in my mind's Pacific are restive.

The strikes Of destruction in the Pacific
are now challenged,
Innumerable are the soldiers of culture
Collisions usher in new horizons of progress.
So the waves in my mind's Pacific are restive.

The depth and power of the Pacific
dissipate the destruction
Multitude march on for peace
Creativity comes alive.
So the waves in my mind's Pacific are restive.

Thursday, November 10, 2011

Bhupen Hazarika: Some random thoughts

Arguably the week in which Bhupen Hazarika( I do not like the tag Dr. before his name)died is the most momentous week in the cultural history of Assam so far. Probably more has been written and talked about him during this week than in the last twenty years.

Most of them are sheer personal reminiscences of some close associates of the great singer and the composer. Insignificant details like what he ate or drank at certain places and so on dominate their musings about the legendary person . These are bound to be heading for oblivion after sometime. We do not know the names of all the soldiers in the battle of Waterloo; neither are they important for us.

But tragically there have been no serious objective evaluation of his works( I am talking of the week only) which is,I feel more important for us and the posterity.

Bhupen Hazarika occupies a unique place in our mind, at least in those who are above forty.But the young generations , specially after the advent of the news channels , tend to remember him as an old and fragile man who sang for Star Cement advertisement.His baritone voice, his lyrics and the perfect blend of harmony with which he cast his musical magic spell upon the sea of humanity who came to see him up close has become a thing of the past.
This is the time to ask ourselves: Why is he great? Why is he one and only?

I am sure many will write about it in the days ahead.

For me Bhupen Hazarika stands out on many counts. some of them, I believe are as follow:

Bhupen Hazarika is the only singer among his contemporaries who could proclaim with unshaken conviction that he is a singer. Listen to his songs:A) Mur gitor hezar shruta tumak namaskar,B)Mur gaan houk bahu ashtha hinotar biporite ek gabhir asthar gaan,C)Samuhor babe git gai gai tumak pahori golu....in all these songs he projects himself as a singer which is not found in any other singers in Assam(and maybe in India). This conviction to claim oneself as a singer and composer is not born overnight. It is a reflection of his deep and years of engagement with music.

There is not a single community or ethnic group that has not found a place in his songs.Be it a tea garden girl(Laxmi nahoi mure naam Chameli) or a Nepali milk man.

His composition embraces all the genres of Assamese music. From Kamrupi lokgit to zikir to Kawali(Samma thakile zaroor zaroor parwana bhi thakibo)to Bihu(Tuk dekhi mur gaa zin zin zaan zaan pir pir paar paar...). In that case his counterpart in literature will surely be Rabindranath Tagore.

Jyotiprasad told about Viswa Nagarik- a global citizen. We are debating Globalization now and many among us who oppose Globalization have taken the maximum benefits from Globalization itself. For them Globalization is synonymous with economics and KFC/MacDonald. But Globalization can have other facets too.Like Globalization of ideas or culture.Listen to his Moi eti zazabor(Aami ek Zazabor in Bangla)and see how wide his vision is. After Jyotiprasad , he is the only one who could transcend the barrier of domesticity and proclaim that he is or he aspires to be a global citizen.

I have listened to many Assamese songs on nature. From Jyotiprasad's Gose gose pati dile phulore sarai to Bishnu Rabha's Bilote halise dhunia podume to Dr.Nirmolprapha Bordoloi's phulore ei melate( Superably alive in Pulak Bannerjee's voice). But these songs are composed from the perspective of viewer only. Nature is just a spectacle. But listen to Bhupen Hazarika's o mur dharitri aai charanote diba thai...here he shows the best relationship between man and nature or in other words between human and non-human world. This is unique. The song was written before our big fuss over deforestation , big dam and peasants'movement. That way he anticipated the future.

A remarkable quality of Bhupen Hazarika was his restraint with which he dealt with the most sensuous. Recall his song dehor randhe randhe tulile sihoron tumar uthor porose.... and see the restraint. Today's singer would have gone into an orgy in such a situation.

Every great singer(or writer) leaves behind a tradition. Had Bhupen Hazarika not listened to Paul Robson's Old man river, he probably could not have composed his timeless song Bistirna parorore...( Unfortunately a TV journalist of the state accuses him of musical plagiarism on this ground. It shows his quality of thought!).

But Bhupen hazarika , so far , has failed to create a tradition. The young generation singers tend to model themselves after some one else rather than this great maestro.

I shall be happy if some one comes soon to sing along his tradition. I shall be happier if it happens in my lifetime.

Bhupen Hazarika , we will miss you.